Customer Reviews

Holy yummi’ness! A perfect cup of tea and smells great when brewing. Such a generous seller and shop! Love the homemade, handmade feel from Fare Isle’s goodies.

OMG Friday night was Perfect!!!! You guys are the best best best!!!!! Three guests said it was the best food and we all loved every minute of it.

Fare Isle Habanero Olive Oil made such a good Xmas gift it had to be re-ordered. Very fast shipping and packed meticulously. Highly recommended!

I love the hot chocolate, and wanted to thank you for making such a delicious recipe. Very impressed!I also love how perfectly everything was wrapped and loved the personal note card. Thank you very much for your extra efforts!

Joy to work with this artisan/seller! FAST shipping, beautiful presentation, and DELICIOUS (according to my parents who received as gift). Thank you!

Everything fresh, seasonal, sustainable, from scratch and ridiculously delicious. From start to finish, Kaity and Jake prepared the most exquisite dinners – done with such integrity, warmth and professionalism. Each experience was such a treat and something to look forward to. Can’t wait for the next!

My husband is OBSESSED with Fare Isle’s Country Style Mustard. He made some fresh organic potato wedges as soon as it arrived just so he could eat some. Thanks for the great customer service as well!

The spices arrived and I wanted to thank you for your kindness. Everything about the presentation is graceful and classy. Thanks!

Amazing vegan products: I bumped into Kaity at the farmer’s market in town on Saturday. I bought the crumb cake, it was simply amazing! She has baked goods plus numerous other vegan products, many of which can be mail ordered.

We want to thank you so very much for all of the work that went into making such a memorable meal.... we were absolutely blown away and so were all our guests. It was beyond anything we could have imagined! Thank you thank you thank you.

Despite the best efforts of Kaity, the original package I received this in was damaged by the USPS and the tea jar was shattered. I contacted Fare Isle immediately and sent a picture of the broken jar. Kaity was wonderful! I couldn’t have asked for a better response from her. She had a replacement sent out two days later and it arrived in perfect condition. The Wild Nantucket Beach Rose Assam Tea itself is lovely: warm and rich with a hint of rose petal. It has quickly become my favorite to have in the afternoons. The packaging itself is so pretty and these make great gifts for tea lovers!

The food is SPECTACULAR! I consider myself a tough critic and this is some of the best food I’ve ever tasted. Jake is truly a gifted chef.

This is my third time ordering the Nantucket Rocket Cider. it is now a staple in my immune boosting arsenal. I will never be without it! I have been using this at the onset of any cold or flu symptoms, throughout the past year. It has worked like a charm. I had to order more, just be sure I am prepared for this year!

Dinner last night was inspiring and delicious! Thank you Jake and Kaity for a memorable and beautiful night!

Kaity, you and Jake were just amazing last night. Everything was so delicious. Thank you!

Just want to thank you and Jake for two remarkable dinners this weekend. Your food is exquisite! We appreciate the love and joy you brought through your cooking to our guests. Best dinners ever! I am grateful we get to do this again!

SUCH a lovely meal. Thank you Jake and Kaity for a really great home chef experience. Exactly what I was hoping for and more!

Your granola is yummy, been sprinkling on my oatmeal in the morning and enjoying every spoonful! The jams delicious, you are amazing! Everything I see you post on facebook looks so good and your stand the market just beautiful.

We all enjoyed The b-day dinner you prepared last night. Everything was absolutely delicious!! You and Jake are a wonderful team.

Just want to extend huge thanks to you and Jake for an amazing dining experience!! The dinner was absolutely delicious, everything was so fresh, full of flavor and visually stunning.  It was a true delight for the senses! There were rave reviews all around and we all spoke about wanting to do another dinner in the future. I am so honoring of what you have created, with so much love and consciousness.  The incredible array of fresh, heirloom ingredients from your gardens, and just the care you take with the blending of flavors and presentation, and with keeping everything local and sustainable. It’s exquisite, really, and feels so in line with my vision of what genuinely good, healthy food should be about.  Huge gratitude to you both for everything.  You made the process so easy and enjoyable. Thanks again!

Dinner was incredible! We had the best night! Thank you. Can't wait to book with you again next time!